NAT-T changes. Matches changes to reference non-nonexistent structs in
sys/netkey.
I have no clue if this is correct, but it matches the style in
sys/netkey, and (unlike the previous two revisions) it actually compiles...
because the sysctl() code wasn't setting the requestor-pid field in dump
responses, the reworked unicast dump wasn't setting the requestor pid, either.
More exaclty, the pid field was set to 0.
No problem for setkey(8), but racoon reportedly ignores SADB dump-responses
with any pid (including 0) which doesn't match its own pid. A private bug
report says the 0-valued pid field broke racoon code which attempts to recover
from death of a prior racoon process, by dumping the SADB at startup.
Fix by revising sys/netipsec, so that both the new unicast PF_KEY dump
responses and the sysctl code set the requestor pid field in all
response mesages to DUMP requests.
Introduce new socket-layer function sbappendaddrchain() to
sys/kern/uipc_socket2.c: like sbappendaddr(), only takes a chain of
records and appends the entire chain in one pass. sbappendaddrchain()
also takes an `sbprio' argument, which indicates the caller requires
special `reliable' handling of the socket-buffer. `sbprio' is
described in sys/sys/socketvar.h, although (for now) the different
levels are not yet implemented.
Rework sys/netipsec/key.c PF_KEY DUMP responses to build a chain of
mbuf records, one record per dump response. Unicast the entire chain
to the requestor, with all-or-none semantics.
Changed files;
sys/socketvar.h kern/uipc_socket2.c netipsec/key.c
Reviewed by:
Jason Thorpe, Thor Lancelot Simon, post to tech-kern.
Todo: request pullup to 2.0 branch. Post-2.0, rework sysctl() API for
dumps to use new record-chain constructors. Actually implement
the distinct service levels in sbappendaddrchain() so we can use them
to make PF_KEY ACQUIRE messages more reliable.
KAME sys/netkey/key.c rev 1.119 ke_sp_unlink()/key_sp_dead() logic.
I have been running a similar version for about 10 days now, and it
fixes the PCB-cache refcount problems for me.
Checked in as a candidate for pullup to the 2.0 branch.
key_prefered_oldsa, defaulted to 1 (on): preferring old SAs, based on
the ill-concieved Jenkins I-D, is broken by design. For now, just
turn it off, as the simplest way to fix this in the 2.0 branch.
Next step is to rip it out entirely: it was always a bad idea.
#1. Fix an off-by-one error in sysctl_net_key_dumpsa(), which was
passing sysctl argument name[1] to a helper. According to Andrew
Brown's revised dynamic sysctl schmea, it must instead pass name[0].
2. There is a naming glitch in using sysctl() for setkey(8): setkey
queries the same sysctl MIB numbers to dump IPsec database state,
irrepesctive of the underlying IPsec is KAME or FAST_IPSEC.
For this to work as expected, sys/netipsec must export net.key.dumpsa
and net.key.dumpsp via the identical MIB numbers used by sys/netkey.
``Make it so''. For now, renumber the sys/netipsec/key.c nodes;
post-2.0 we can use sysctl aliases.
3. For as-yet-unexplained reasons, the PF_KEY_V2 nodes are never
shown (or queried?) by sysctl(8). For 2.0, I am following an earlier
suggestion from Andrew Brown, and renumbering allthe FAST_IPSEC sysctl
nodes to appear under net.key at MIB number { CTL_NET, PF_KEY }. Since
the renumbering may change, the renumbering is done via a level of
indirection in the C preprocessor.
The nett result is that setkey(8) can find the nodes it needs for
setkey -D and setkey -PD: and that sysctl(8) finds all the FAST_IPSEC
sysctl nodes relatedy to IPsec keying, under net.key. Andrew Brown
has reviewed this patch and tentatively approved the changes, though
we may rework some of the changes in -current in the near future.
SPDs, and to warn about and reject any such attempts.
Addresses a security concern, that the (eas-yet incomplete, experimental)
FAST_IPSEC+INET6 does not honour IPv6 SPDs. The security risk is that
Naive users may not realize this, and their data may get leaked in
cleartext, rather than IPsec'ed, if they use IPv6.
Security issue raised by: Thor Lancelot Simon
reviewed and OKed by: Thor Lancelot Simon
2.0 Pullup request after: 24 hours for further public comment.
(MD5 signatures for TCP, as used with BGP). Credit for original
FreeBSD code goes to Bruce M. Simpson, with FreeBSD sponsorship
credited to sentex.net. Shortening of the setsockopt() name
attributed to Vincent Jardin.
This commit is a minimal, working version of the FreeBSD code, as
MFC'ed to FreeBSD-4. It has received minimal testing with a ttcp
modified to set the TCP-MD5 option; BMS's additions to tcpdump-current
(tcpdump -M) confirm that the MD5 signatures are correct. Committed
as-is for further testing between a NetBSD BGP speaker (e.g., quagga)
and industry-standard BGP speakers (e.g., Cisco, Juniper).
NOTE: This version has two potential flaws. First, I do see any code
that verifies recieved TCP-MD5 signatures. Second, the TCP-MD5
options are internally padded and assumed to be 32-bit aligned. A more
space-efficient scheme is to pack all TCP options densely (and
possibly unaligned) into the TCP header ; then do one final padding to
a 4-byte boundary. Pre-existing comments note that accounting for
TCP-option space when we add SACK is yet to be done. For now, I'm
punting on that; we can solve it properly, in a way that will handle
SACK blocks, as a separate exercise.
In case a pullup to NetBSD-2 is requested, this adds sys/netipsec/xform_tcp.c
,and modifies:
sys/net/pfkeyv2.h,v 1.15
sys/netinet/files.netinet,v 1.5
sys/netinet/ip.h,v 1.25
sys/netinet/tcp.h,v 1.15
sys/netinet/tcp_input.c,v 1.200
sys/netinet/tcp_output.c,v 1.109
sys/netinet/tcp_subr.c,v 1.165
sys/netinet/tcp_usrreq.c,v 1.89
sys/netinet/tcp_var.h,v 1.109
sys/netipsec/files.netipsec,v 1.3
sys/netipsec/ipsec.c,v 1.11
sys/netipsec/ipsec.h,v 1.7
sys/netipsec/key.c,v 1.11
share/man/man4/tcp.4,v 1.16
lib/libipsec/pfkey.c,v 1.20
lib/libipsec/pfkey_dump.c,v 1.17
lib/libipsec/policy_token.l,v 1.8
sbin/setkey/parse.y,v 1.14
sbin/setkey/setkey.8,v 1.27
sbin/setkey/token.l,v 1.15
Note that the preceding two revisions to tcp.4 will be
required to cleanly apply this diff.
used to short-circuit IPsec processing in other places.
This is enabled only for NetBSD at the moment; in order for it to function
correctly, ipsec_pcbconn() must be called as appropriate.
va_{start,end} audit:
Make sure that each va_start has one and only one matching va_end,
especially in error cases.
If the va_list is used multiple times, do multiple va_starts/va_ends.
If a function gets va_list as argument, don't let it use va_end (since
it's the callers responsibility).
Improved by comments from enami and christos -- thanks!
Heimdal/krb4/KAME changes already fed back, rest to follow.
Inspired by, but not not based on, OpenBSD.
The idea is that we only clear M_CANFASTFWD if an SPD exists
for the packet. Otherwise, it's safe to add a fast-forward
cache entry for the route.
To make this work properly, we invalidate the entire ipflow
cache if a fast-ipsec key is added or changed.
Gone are the old kern_sysctl(), cpu_sysctl(), hw_sysctl(),
vfs_sysctl(), etc, routines, along with sysctl_int() et al. Now all
nodes are registered with the tree, and nodes can be added (or
removed) easily, and I/O to and from the tree is handled generically.
Since the nodes are registered with the tree, the mapping from name to
number (and back again) can now be discovered, instead of having to be
hard coded. Adding new nodes to the tree is likewise much simpler --
the new infrastructure handles almost all the work for simple types,
and just about anything else can be done with a small helper function.
All existing nodes are where they were before (numerically speaking),
so all existing consumers of sysctl information should notice no
difference.
PS - I'm sorry, but there's a distinct lack of documentation at the
moment. I'm working on sysctl(3/8/9) right now, and I promise to
watch out for buses.
repository by christos was part 1). netipsec should now be back as it
was on 2003-09-11, with some very minor changes:
1) Some residual platform-dependent code was moved from ipsec.h to
ipsec_osdep.h; without this, IPSEC_ASSERT() was multiply defined. ipsec.h
now includes ipsec_osdep.h
2) itojun's renaming of netipsec/files.ipsec to netipsec/files.netipsec has
been left in place (it's arguable which name is less confusing but the
rename is pretty harmless).
3) Some #endif TOKEN has been replaced by #endif /* TOKEN */; #endif TOKEN
is invalid and GCC 3 won't compile it.
An i386 kernel with "options FAST_IPSEC" and "options OPENCRYPTO" now
gets through "make depend" but fails to build with errors in ip_input.c.
But it's better than it was (thank heaven for small favors).
Fast-IPsec is a rework of the OpenBSD and KAME IPsec code, using the
OpenCryptoFramework (and thus hardware crypto accelerators) and
numerous detailed performance improvements.
This import is (aside from SPL-level names) the FreeBSD source,
imported ``as-is'' as a historical snapshot, for future maintenance
and comparison against the FreeBSD source. For now, several minor
kernel-API differences are hidden by macros a shim file, ipsec_osdep.h,
which (aside from SPL names) can be targeted at either NetBSD or FreeBSD.
